Here’s The Scoop: Authentic Gelato Guide

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Summer is here AKA the season of frozen dessert. Although ice cream and slushies have long dominated our North American childhood memories, gelato is steadily taking over the Toronto food scene.

It's an image by Roman Odintsov. Two hands are shown holding strawberry ice creams on cones.

Invented by Bernardo Buontalenti, gelato technically means frozen. The 16th-century Florentine stage designer, architect, theatrical designer, and military engineer is credited with inventing the dessert. There is even a gelato flavour named after him, made using milk, sugar, cream and eggs, though his original version was flavoured with bergamot, lemons, oranges and dessert wine. It can be served in a cup, cone, or with espresso poured over top to make an affogato. Though it has similarities to ice cream, the Italian frozen dessert is a league of its own.


Regardless of where it is made, gelato’s base ingredients stay the same, though there are a few regional differences. For example, gelato made in northern Italy often has more cream and includes egg yolks to help thicken the mixture and prevent ice crystals from forming. Cornstarch is more commonly used as a thickening agent in southern Italy.

An image by Jéshoots. In the image, there is an assortment of different flavours of Gelato in metal trays with blue spades

Traditional gelato starts with a custard base. Once the ingredients are properly emulsified, the mixture is flavoured with things like chocolate, chopped pistachios or fruit. It is then slowly churned as it cools, either by machine or by hand to make gelato artigianale, which is artisanal gelato in English. The slow mixing prevents excess air bubbles from being folded into the cream, which is what gives gelato its rich, thick texture.


Gelato and ice cream are both frozen dairy-based desserts, though there are a few key differences. Compared to ice cream, gelato has less fat and air in the mixture, so it is served at warmer temperatures. In line with Italian food traditions, authentic Italian gelato uses simple ingredients — milk, sugar, and real fruit or chocolate to add flavour — and does not include preservatives, chemicals, artificial flavours or artificial colours. As a result, gelaterias will often keep their gelato in metal containers, since gelato artigianale melts quicker than products containing preservatives or stabilizing ingredients. Gelato is served with a spade, which allows servers to shape and soften the gelato, while ice cream is served with a scoop, which keeps it round and fluffy.

An image by Keriliwi shows a girl holding out a gelato cone in funky beige shades. In this image, the Gelato is the only focus, the rest of the image is blurred.

Despite gelato’s artisanal appeal, freezer aisles in grocery stores are stocked with mostly ice cream. The invention of the hand-crank freezer in the 1840s created a bit of a setback for gelato, paving the way for the industrial ice cream industry. In recent years, gelato is gaining steam once again, as the farm-to-table and slow food movements gain popularity in Canada.


Are you wondering where to find gelato artigianale in Toronto? Keep reading for ICCO Canada’s essential gelateria list.

An Instagram screenshot. The image is split in 2, on the left is person holding A gelato cone from Mizzia Getao on the streets of Toronto with the CN Tower in the background and out of focus. On the right is the caption that says What looked like a gloomy Friday was instead one of the most fun, hot and busy days filled with the loveliest customers!
We hope you enjoyed Canada day and we wish you a fun weekend ahead!
We have new exciting flavours coming and can’t wait to spend a new whole month with all of you.
Happy first of July!

Mizzica Gelateria & Cafe is serving up some of Toronto’s best traditional Italian gelato and treats. Hailing from Sicily, owners Paolo Di Lallo and Denise Pisani are known for their fresh weekly flavours of gelato made from scratch, including the popular Bronte pistachio gelato the shop is known for. Compared to other pistachios, Sicilian pistachios are known for their sweeter and richer flavour. The secret is in the Mount Etna region’s volcanic soil.

An Instagram screenshot. the image is split in 2 halves. The left image shows assorted gelatos on metal trays with spades. 

On the right is the caption of the image i.e. One of the questions we get asked the most is: What is the difference between Gelato and Ice Cream? 

In Italian Gelato literally means “Frozen.” Gelato sets itself apart from Ice Cream as it is prepared using milk instead of cream and it contains no egg yolk.

Also, Gelato is stored roughly 10 degrees warmer than ice cream, making it feel much smoother 

Our gelato is prepared using natural and premium quality ingredients, which allow us to make the number 1 Gelato in Ontario!

We also offer Vegan Gelato options, prepared with locally sourced ingredients such as Ontario Strawberries and Blue grapes, delicious Alphonso Mangos, dairy-free Belgian Dark Chocolate and much more!!!

Punto Gelato was recognized by ICCO Canada in 2019 for having the best gelato in Ontario. Carrying over 100 flavours, their gelato is made fresh daily and served out of traditional metal containers at their three locations. Additionally, Punto Gelato can prepare a gelato cake or pie for your next celebration.

An Instagram screenshot. The image is split into 2 halves. on the left is an image of Carlotta's Gelato on a waffle cone with a wafer on top. On the right is the caption that says - If you know, you know.

Lastly is Il Gelato di Carlotta, run by Carlotta Cattani. The Cattani family is originally from Florence, which is where gelato was first created. After moving to Canada, Carlotta was determined to bring her passion for authentic Italian gelato to Ontario, using a mixture of ingredients sourced locally or imported from Italy, such as hazelnuts from Piemonte.

“In Italy, gelato isn’t just dessert. It is popular as a merenda, which is a late afternoon snack in the hours after lunch and before aperitivo,” says Carlotta Cattani, president and director of production and flavour development, Il Gelato di Carlotta. “In almost any Italian town during the late afternoon you’ll see plenty of people strolling around with gelato in hand.”

Cool off with a scoop of classic Italian gelato this summer. Buon appetito!


  • No comments yet.
  • Add a comment

    Welcome to!

    ICCO Canada and The True Italian Taste project are happy to introduce, our newest tool to inform consumers about how to consciously purchase and enjoy 100% made-in-Italy products. Find updates on the latest food and wine trends and everything you need to know about authentic Italian cuisine.

    The True Italian Taste project is promoted and financed by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation and carried out by Assocamerestero in collaboration with the Italian Chambers of Commerce abroad.

    ICCO Canada is the catalyst to developing business and cultural alliances among visionaries, entrepreneurs, and global organizations in Canada and in Italy.